.

Kenneth Roy

The expert view is wrong.
These deaths could
have been prevented

Bob Cant

What does
'Tutti Frutti'

say to us now?


6

John Cameron

The great 'Chariots
of Fire' was the
purest hokum

4

7

Andrew Hook

Down with
everything: the new
American mantra

5

7

Ronnie Smith

Tanned and smiling,
Mr Blair arrives
among us

5

7

Islay McLeod

Villages of
Scotland:
(3) Thornhill

5

18.01.12
No. 502

The Cafe 2

John Cameron has done a disservice to distinguished Czech playwright and statesman Vaclav Havel, and seems unable to acknowledge a simple error of mis-attribution. The story so far is that in his piece (20 December) following Havel's death, John Cameron wrote the following:
     Though a Czech Green Party member, he was an excoriating critic of global warming, describing it as 'a metaphysical ideology with nothing to do with the natural sciences'. He dismissed the IPCC as 'a neo-political body; a non-government organisation of green flavour. It is neither a scientific institution nor a balanced forum of climate scientists'.
     
In fact, the views and words he attributes to Havel are those of Vaclav Klaus (political opponent of Havel, free market zealot, and intemperate climate change denier). After I pointed this out, John Cameron responded with a further attempt to co-opt Havel to the cause of climate change denial.
     
In truth, Havel's words of caution against accepting evidence uncritically, and attributing climate change to any single cause, would be agreed, it seems to me, by any judicious student of climate change, and certainly do not suggest that Havel denied the probability of man-made climate change or the necessity of policies to restrain it. Unfortunately, Cameron does not give us the source for the Havel quotation, but one can recognise almost all of its wording in this 2007 New York Times article by Havel, in which he also wrote:
     It is also obvious from published research that human activity is a cause of change; we just don’t know how big its contribution is. Is it necessary to know that to the last percentage point, though? By waiting for incontrovertible precision, aren’t we simply wasting time when we could be taking measures that are relatively painless compared to those we would have to adopt after further delays? Maybe we should start considering our sojourn on earth as a loan. There can be no doubt that for the past hundred years at least, Europe and the United States have been running up a debt, and now other parts of the world are following their example. Nature is issuing warnings that we must not only stop the debt from growing but start to pay it back. There is little point in asking whether we have borrowed too much or what would happen if we postponed the repayments. Anyone with a mortgage or a bank loan can easily imagine the answer.
     Readers may wish to read the article in full and judge whether John Cameron's quotes represent a fair and balanced representation of Havel's position. What is beyond doubt, however, is that John Cameron's original characterisation of Havel as an 'excoriating critic of global warming' is simply wrong and, as I have suggested, does a singular disservice to a distinguished figure of our times.

Terry Moody


 

www.bobsmithart.com

 

 



Best fans? The Shire

Best stovies? Queen of

the South

 

Part II of Football, friendship and 'the 42'


Gerry Hassan

 

The whole day out to Peterhead was enjoyable and entertaining and made me reflect. This was a warm, sociable group of Celtic fans. There were no pub bores or people who dominated the conversation of the whole bus. There was leadership, organisation and a culture of soft collective discipline.
     Some of the songs being sung on the way up wouldn't pass the Offensive Behaviour Act 2011. But what do I make of that? Singing of the hunger strikes and Bobby Sands is not something I really want as part of modern 21st-century Scotland, but I also don't want to ban it in a bus. The song about the 1971 Ibrox disaster and making light of its tragedy is more than awful bad taste, but then the law shouldn't be involved in the universal stupidity of football fans to sing offensive ditties about their main rivals.
     Most of the young men on the bus lived in one of the poorest parts of Glasgow, and were a mix of guys in employment, often in jobs they openly expressed their hatred for or boredom in, and some who were unemployed. They were animated, articulate and intensely knowledgeable about football. In the course of an entire day, I didn't hear one sexist or racist comment, or outwith their singing, a sectarian or offensive comment.
     Some would call these guys chancers or scallies, but if they were they were charming, filled with camaraderie and good-natured. These were mostly men at the start of their adult lives and to be serious for a moment, they showed a different side of Scotland. These guys dodged the forces of law and order, drank a lot, took illegal drugs, sang some offensive songs and engaged in a bit of shoplifting. There are clearly lots of these young men who have various 'issues', whether it is finding decent employment, relations with law and order and wider authority, or who have already experienced jail.
     These were, from my short impression, decent lads who have grown up in circumstances where this has been the norm. In this context, they showed thoughtfulness and consideration for other members of their group, were friendly and respectful to myself and Eddie who were strangers to them, and were never too boyish or out of control.
     Eddie and myself set out on our 42-ground grand tour to see the Scotland on the other side of the tracks football-wise, and to do something as friends. We ended up via Peterhead and other places seeing another side of Scotland. We met lots of warm, friendly people; we went to towns we would never normally go to, and we ate in cafes and pubs in town centres across our land. We went to towns some people didn’t know existed or even where they were (Stenhousemuir, where I nearly dragged a BBC film crew – it was the Saturday after the SNP landslide victory), or that they had league teams. We ate and drank in some memorable places from the British Legion in Dingwall to bars by grounds such as Arbroath and in grounds such as East Fife.

 

Maybe most of all apart from what we learnt about ourselves and our friendship, for both of us it has offered the opportunity to tell friends and acquaintances a very different story about Scotland.


     We even watched one game: Albion Rovers v East Fife where we got the teams the wrong way round, leaving thinking the mighty Albion had recorded a rare 4-1 victory to find out otherwise after the game. We watched Gretna play what turned out to be their last-ever league match at Raydale Park as they failed to clinch promotion against St Johnstone (they won it the following week); we weren't impressed with the ground (or Gretna) to put it mildly.
     And then to our last game, Saturday 14 January 2012, Berwick Rangers v Stranraer, and a fitting swansong it turned out to be. Arriving well over half an hour before kick off, we had magnificent fish and chips from a food emporium in the ground. I then asked someone to take a photograph of myself and Eddie to capture the occasion, who turned out to be the club doctor, Alan Fortune. He then proceeded to take several photographs of us for use in the next home programme, and arranged for an announcement to be made at half-time over the tannoy that we had completed 'the 42' and had chosen Berwick as the site for this historic occasion.
     We witnessed a superb game of football with two skilled teams playing a passing game with loads of chances. It was a great advert for division three and finished at the end two a piece with Berwick perhaps a shade unlucky not just to shave it.
     The whole experience has been incredibly positive, a deeper glimpse into a Scotland most people don't give a second thought for, some glorious, entertaining football, and surprisingly few stinkers, and a real sense of two friends spending time with each other.
     Maybe most of all, apart from what we learned about ourselves and our friendship, for both of us it has offered the opportunity to tell friends and acquaintances a very different story about Scotland, one which isn't about football tribes, labels or judging others, but instead showing a sense of curiosity, discovery and empathy for others.
     As for the best supporters? Without a doubt Eddie and I give our unanimous 10 points each to East Stirling who don't even have a home ground (playing at Stenhousemuir). And the best pie? Well the best food in my mind, superbly cooked and presented, was Queen of the South's stovies.

 

Click here for Part I of Football, friendship and 'the 42'

 

Gerry Hassan is a writer, commentator and policy analyst, author and editor of 14 books on Scottish and British politics, policy and ideas