In the early weeks of his inquiry into the case of Bailey Gwynne, the 16-year-old boy who was stabbed to death by a fellow pupil of Cults Academy, there were rumours that Andrew Lowe, the child protection expert appointed to conduct the review, was not receiving the degree of co-operation that he might have expected and to which he was entitled.

It was not that Mr Lowe was being actively impeded in the course of his duties. That would be going too far. But perhaps – so the rumours went – there were limits to his ease of access to important case papers.

The suggestion that some of those involved may not have been wildly keen on his investigation has hardly been dispelled by the handling of his 17,000-word report on the chronology of the case, the background of the killer, the relationship between the two boys, and the role of the school.

After Mr Lowe had finished his work, there was a delay of a month in doing anything with it. Last week, his findings and recommendations were finally published. But the 17,000-word narrative? We’re still waiting for that. We may go on waiting for some time.

The official explanation of the three co-sponsors – Aberdeen City Council, NHS Grampian and Police Scotland – is that the full report cannot be released for 'legal and data protection reasons’. It seems that the content is terribly sensitive: so sensitive that some of the parties whose permission is required prior to publication are not responding with the alacrity that the distressing circumstances should have demanded.

The fact that much of the material is sensitive should not have come as a surprise to any of these parties (which may include Police Scotland). It should have been anticipated and dealt with. The judicial process was completed as long ago as March with the conviction and subsequent detention of the killer. What, then, are those 'legal and data protection’ issues? There is such a thing as redaction: anything deemed somehow inappropriate for public consumption could have been blacked at any stage in the last month.

Mr Lowe himself has confided in the Evening Express, Aberdeen, that he is 'frustrated’ by the delay and that he wants the public to be able to read his work. As well he might, if for no other reason than that his findings and recommendations are pretty meaningless without the narrative to back them up.

For the moment, then, the full story remains untold. And there is one particularly mystifying feature of the case that one hopes Mr Lowe’s report – if it ever sees the light of day – will resolve one way or the other. It concerns two disputed versions of an incident in the early life of the killer.

BBC Scotland reported after his conviction, but before sentencing, that in 2007, eight years before the death of Bailey Gwynne, he threw rocks at another child and that the incident resulted in the victim being treated for concussion. The victim’s parents contacted the police and the school, but – according to the couple – no effective action was taken.

Fearful that the attacker would go on to commit a far more serious crime, they got in touch with a local councillor, Marie Boulton, and their MP, Anne Begg, both of whom were sympathetic. 'They were not satisfied that their children were going to be safe going to school’, said Anne Begg.

This apparently well-sourced BBC report had a potentially serious implication. It raised the possibility that, if the police and the school had taken appropriate action at the time, Bailey Gwynne might still be alive. At the sentencing hearing, however, the killer’s defence counsel insisted that ‘media reports’ that the killer had been involved in an earlier incident were 'quite markedly inaccurate’.

At his press conference, Mr Lowe agreed that some incident of the sort had occurred – while casting doubt on its significance 'in relation to later events'. We can only guess what this means; without the narrative there is no way of understanding or evaluating Mr Lowe's statement or the claim in court that the BBC report was 'quite markedly inaccurate’.

Meanwhile, it is disappointing to learn that the killer – whose counsel assured the court that he 'genuinely recognised’ the gravity of his crime and genuinely repented of it – refused Mr Lowe’s request for an interview. Clearly the rehabilitation of the offender remains a work in progress.

Return to homepage

SR Week
Bailey Gwynne: The untold story: 18 October

Revisiting the Dunblane tragedy: 13 October

Revisiting the Orkney child abuse scandal:
6 October

Suspected of murder: 29 September

Kenneth Roy’s new book, ‘The Broken Journey: a life of Scotland 1976-99’, will be published at the end of this month. In its 500+ pages, 'The Broken Journey' charts in vivid and compelling detail the events and personalities of the last quarter of the 20th century in Scotland.

Published in hardback by Birlinn, ‘The Broken Journey’ is available direct from the Scottish Review at £30 (inc. p&p). Advance copies have just arrived. To obtain your copy or copies ahead of official publication, call 01292 478510 with your credit/debit card details – or click below.



Click here to go to the October edition

Kenneth Roy: The Scots who have 'had enough' expose the myth of our democracy

Walter Humes: The concept of 'wellbeing' does not begin to touch the reality of children's lives

Eileen Reid: I cannot access a wonder drug for my treatment without fear of prosecution

Alan McIntyre: Transparency is a double-edged sword that restricts frank debate

Gerry Hassan: Corbyn fails to grasp that he is meant to speak for the whole country

R D Kernohan: Are the Tories nice or nasty? Theresa May must set the tone

David Torrance: I ended up snogging a young female artist in Anchorage's only gay bar

Bob Smith: Cartoons

Ruth Morrissy: The Irish women forced into temporary exile by an iniquitous law

Ronnie Smith: Tribalism is everwhere in Scotland, not only at football stadia

Alasdair McKillop: It is unclear how the SNP will win over those still resisting its charms

Andrew Hook: Do I sit anonymously at the back wearing dark glasses?

Eloise Vajk: If you want to test yourself, stand between humanity and its next hot meal

Josh Moir: We need to find a value in people who don't act like celebrities in reality shows

The November edition of SR will be online on the 1st of next month