Search the SR website:

11 March 2020
  • Home
  • Sign up free
  • Become a Friend


Bill Paterson is admirably clear on the faults and flaws of the various electoral systems currently in use in Scotland at different elections. Like him, I believe the single transferable vote (STV), while still not perfect, gives a more accurate representation of how an electorate voted than most other systems. The downside is that it can lead to horse-trading among parties once the result is in, but what system doesn't? Even first-past-the-post (FPTP), especially when more than two parties are involved, results in either horse-trading or an outcome grossly unrepresentative of the way people actually voted.

There is absolutely zero prospect of electoral reform coming from Westminster, as the present system undoubtedly suits the Conservative Party and until very recently suited the Labour Party, which would no doubt find it still does should it ever again form a UK Government. The adoption of STV for Scottish elections should happen regardless of what is going on at Westminster, but would surely be a positive feature of an independent Scotland.

James Robertson

2

SR published a most innovative article last week in the Cafe on the need for 'reforms' in Scottish governance. Might I suggest that this could become a furrow worth following with a regular feature offered to the public. 

Thom Cross

2

If you would like to contribute to the Cafe, please email your comments to islay@scottishreview.net


Return to homepage

1UPFRONT
Maurice Smith
The Salmond trial:
'Woman H' gives evidence

COMMENTARY
Gerry Hassan
The dark side of Scottish men

HEALTH
Bill Paterson
In the battle for our nation's health,
who do you trust?

NOTEBOOK
Morelle Smith
The woman who could have
become Queen of Albania

DESPATCH

Keith Aitken
Using Article 49.3 was a pretty
neat trick by Philippe

ENVIRONMENT
Alastair Osborne
East Ayrshire could have its
very own Eden

MEDIA
Hamish Mackay
Public service broadcasting reform,
Dorothy Byrne's new role at
Channel 4, and more

TRAVEL
John McGrath
Borders dividing an island represent failure

CAFE
SR Forum
Should Scotland adopt the STV system?

CARTOONS

Bob Smith
Just what is cronyvirus?

Scotland's weekly current affairs magazine
Sign up free

Editorial

  • Editor
    Islay McLeod

  • Founder

    SR was established in 1995
    by Kenneth Roy

Contact Us

Prestwick International Airport,
Liberator House, Room 216,
Prestwick KA9 2PT
01292 478510
admin@scottishreview.net

Quick Links

Become a Friend of SR
Subscribe to SR
About Us

The Scottish Review is published weekly by the Institute of Contemporary Scotland (ICS)