Search the SR website:

21 October 2020
  • Home
  • Sign up free
  • Become a Friend


Having read Tom Chidwick's piece in last week's Scottish Review, I think that New St Andrew's House, opened in 1975 and demolished recently, had a lot more wrong with it than its ugly, overbearing appearance. Its very name misled many people, invited to attend meetings, to turn up at the other St Andrew's House – a quarter-mile away as the crow flies, but rather longer on a slightly complicated walk.
 
The windows couldn't be opened. Air was circulated through an overhead system of pipes which had some apparently incurable fault, so water regularly sprayed down into a room where legal documents were stored. To clean the windows, there was a railway on the roof from which the cleaners could be lowered in a cradle by ropes. Except for a higher section, whose 7th- and 8th-storey windows required the erection of scaffolding to clean them, every year or so.
 
From its opening, a rumour circulated that asbestos had been used in the building's construction. This was officially denied, until a small repair to a ceiling panel proved it to be true. Thereafter, a man was employed to test every room, every week, for any trace of asbestos dust in the air. 
 
The corners weren't all at (boring!) 90-degree angles, and in walking along the corridors you soon lost your bearings, so internal walls were removed to give access to windows with a view of the outside surroundings. Several times I met strangers, totally lost, trying to find their way out. 'Go along here, turn left, get into the lift, go down to the second floor, turn right, then left and get into the other lift. That'll take you down to the entrance hall', would be my helpful advice.
 
'Raw, muscular, angular, concrete Brutalism'? Oh yes, it's 'art' – like somebody's unmade bed. 
 
Bring on the bulldozers! There will always be photographs which record these examples of a (hopefully) bygone architectural fashion.
 
Harry Jack

2

As I live on the 16th/top floor of an Aberdeen beachfront multi-storey, dog-owning is neither practical nor sensible. However, excitingly, a 'virtual' friend has entered my life – Sprout, a cross Labrador/Golden Retriever – whom I am sponsoring through the Guide Dogs for the Blind Association's splendid Sponsor a Puppy project. I have absolutely no inkling why he has the nomenclature of Sprout... I will have to investigate his lineage.

Sprout is six-weeks old and about to embark on 24 months training. His photograph already adorns my living room wall – with the poor chap looking ever so melancholy. I have intended to sponsor a puppy for many years – my interest in the association sparked in the 1970s when a colleague at the Press and Journal, features editor, Pearl Murray, wrote a memorable series of articles on its training centre in Forfar.

I have always loved dogs from the bygone days of our ever-so-loyal black and white collie, Prince, whom, as I was growing up, roamed my home village of Armadale, North Sutherland, with gay abandon. He simply adored showing his great cunning by lying await in ditches before springing out to ferociously attack the tyres of anything on wheels. Welcome on board wee fellow!
 
Hamish Mackay

2


If you would like to contribute to the Cafe, please email your comments to islay@scottishreview.net


Return to homepage

1
HEALTH
Anthony Seaton
COVID-19: the child is father to the man

COMMENTARY
Gerry Hassan
The insider class of Scotland and the UK

DESPATCH
Keith Aitken
If you have to ask, you're not French

CARTOONS
Bob Smith
The Great British Cake Off...

NOTEBOOK
Eileen Reid
I have finally done something about
my lifelong procrastination

PHILOSOPHY
Robin Downie
Authority and expertise in ethics

HISTORY
David Torrance
In search of Prime Ministerial graves

MEDIA
Hamish Mackay
British Journalism Awards, double success for BBC Scotland, and more

WORLD
David Mackenzie
The fight for nuclear disarmament continues

BOOKS
Andrew Hook
Could Shuggie Bain win the
2020 Booker Prize?

SOCIETY
David Macfarlane
Eric Drummond and the League of Nations

LIFE
Charles Gibb
Mrs Wall sacked us on the spot

CAFE 1
SR Forum
Bring on the bulldozers!

CAFE 2
SR Forum
The Empire strikes back

2
To access previous editions of SR,
click on the links below

14 OCTOBER 2020

7 OCTOBER 2020

30 SEPTEMBER 2020

23 SEPTEMBER 2020

16 SEPTEMBER 2020

9 SEPTEMBER 2020

2 SEPTEMBER 2020

Follow us on:


Scotland's weekly current affairs magazine
Sign up free

Editorial

  • Editor
    Islay McLeod

  • Founder

    SR was established in 1995
    by Kenneth Roy

Contact Us

Prestwick International Airport,
Liberator House, Room 216,
Prestwick KA9 2PT
01292 478510
admin@scottishreview.net

Quick Links

Become a Friend of SR
Subscribe to SR
About Us

The Scottish Review is published weekly by the Institute of Contemporary Scotland (ICS)